Data driven analysis, modeling, and semi-supervised machine learning for qualitative and quantitative determinations

ABSTRACT

Systems and methods are provided for data driven analysis, modeling, and semi-supervised machine learning for qualitative and quantitative determinations. The systems and methods include obtaining data associated with individuals, and determining features associated with the individuals based on the data and similarities among the individuals based on the features. The systems and methods can label some individuals as exemplary, generate a graph wherein nodes of the graph represent individuals, edges of the graph represent similarity among the individuals, and nodes associated labeled individuals are weighted. The disclosed system and methods can apply a weight to unweighted nodes of the graph based on propagating the labels through the graph where the propagation is based on influence exerted by the weighted nodes on the unweighted nodes. The disclosed systems and methods can provide output associated with the individuals represented on the graph and the associated weights.

REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation of U.S. Non-Provisional patentapplication Ser. No. 15/170,780, filed on Jun. 1, 2016, the disclosureof which is expressly incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.

BACKGROUND

An ever increasing amount of data and data sources are now available toresearchers, analysts, organizational entities, and others. This influxof information allows for sophisticated analysis to solve problems anddraw conclusions, but in some areas, the availability of conclusionsfrom this data is lacking.

Often, large data sets can contain data points falling into one ormultiple known categories. The number of data points that are easilyclassifiable, however are often limited and do not provide practicalbenefit. Moreover, the remaining data points can often provide no clearindication regarding their appropriate categorization. Effective ways toexpand the number of categorized data points can be time consuming andrequire large amounts of manual intervention.

Without effective data driven methods to analyze and expand thecategorized data sets, users of the data sets cannot draw effectiveconclusions about the data as a whole.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

Reference will now be made to the accompanying drawings showing exampleembodiments of this disclosure. In the drawings:

FIG. 1 is a block diagram of an exemplary system for data drivenanalysis, modeling, and semi-supervised machine learning, consistentwith embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 2 is a block diagram of an exemplary computing device, consistentwith embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 3 is a block diagram of an exemplary computing device, consistentwith embodiments of the present disclosure.

FIG. 4 is an exemplary data structure consistent with embodiments of thepresent disclosure.

FIG. 5 is an exemplary data structure consistent with embodiments of thepresent disclosure.

FIG. 6 is an exemplary data structure consistent with embodiments of thepresent disclosure.

FIG. 7 is an exemplary data structure consistent with embodiments of thepresent disclosure.

FIG. 8 is an exemplary graph consistent with embodiments of the presentdisclosure.

FIG. 9 is an exemplary graph consistent with embodiments of the presentdisclosure.

FIG. 10 is a flowchart of an exemplary method for data driven analysis,modeling, and semi-supervised machine learning, consistent withembodiments of the present disclosure.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

Reference will now be made in detail to the exemplary embodimentsimplemented according to the present disclosure, the examples of whichare illustrated in the accompanying drawings. Wherever possible, thesame reference numbers will be used throughout the drawings to refer tothe same or like parts.

The embodiments described herein relate to data driven analysis,modeling, and semi-supervised machine learning for qualitative andquantitative determinations. In many domains, determining good and badprofessionals present a real challenge. Often, websites or forums areused where consumers can post and read reviews. Often, particularly indomains such as healthcare, these reviews can be highly subjective andbased on criteria that may not be important to the reader. Moreover, insome domains, like healthcare, there are often very few if any reviewsfor a given physician. Choosing a good or bad doctor can be furthercomplicated by the need to ensure that a physician accepts certaininsurance payments. Even if a patient finds a good doctor based onreviews, that doctor may not accept the patient's insurance.

Some systems have attempted to solve these problems, but those systemssimilarly rely on faulty or unreliable information. For example, somemethods for establishing physician quality can rely on academiccredentials. These methods, however, are biased against physicians whomay be excellent but do not have a degree from an esteemed medicalschool. Additionally, reliance on criteria like academic credentials ordemographics uses a false assumption that all physicians who went to ahighly regarded medical school are necessarily good doctors.

The embodiments disclosed herein approach these problems from adifferent perspective. Instead of making broad assumptions based onsmall amounts of data, the disclosed systems and methods process vastamounts of data and use data driven approaches of analysis, such assemi-supervised machine learning to identify good and bad doctors.Instead of only analyzing small, discrete elements of a physician'sbackground or history, the disclosed system places no limit on theamount or type of information that is available for analysis. Inaddition to demographic information, the disclosed system and methodscan utilize claims data, prescription data, scholarship, patientfeedback, proprietary information, and any other available data. Thesystems disclosed can process that data in an efficient and effectiveway to create data structures that can be used to group physicians whoare similar not only by where they went to school, but by countlessfactors culled from the available data.

After exemplary good and bad doctors are found, additional doctors whodisplay similar characteristics can further be added. These physicians,that represent only a small number of the physicians a patient mightsee, can then be analyzed by applying concepts such as electrostaticmodeling and point charge propagation to model how similarities amongthe physicians affect determinations about quality. Although theanalysis can utilize both subjective and objective data inputs, themodeling allows for determinations to be made without traditionalbiases, like subjective quality of medical school, affecting theidentification of good and bad doctors. Using this process, users of thesystem can draw conclusions about the quality of a vast number ofphysicians from known information about a few. Patients can be providedwith much better information about physicians in their insurancenetworks without relying on unreliable information like minimal reviewsand insurance network providers can utilize this system to ensure theycover high quality physicians.

The embodiments described herein provide technologies and techniques forusing vast amounts of available data (originating from different datasources) to drive analysis, modeling, and semi-supervised machinelearning approaches to make determinations about the quality ofprofessionals in a field. Embodiments described herein include systemsand methods for obtaining, from one or more data sources, one or moredata sets associated with a plurality of individuals and determiningfeatures associated with the plurality of individuals wherein thefeatures are based on data in the one or more data sets among theplurality of individuals. The embodiments herein further includelabeling a subset of the plurality of individuals as exemplary,determining similarities among the plurality of individuals, wherein thedetermination of similarities is based on an evaluation of thedetermined features, generating data representing a graph having aplurality of nodes, wherein nodes of the graph are associated with theplurality of individuals, edges between the nodes represent thedetermined similarities, wherein the nodes include unweighted node andweighted nodes, applying a weight to unweighted nodes of the graph,wherein the weights are based on an influence exerted by the weightednodes on the unweighted nodes, providing output associated the graph andthe associated weights.

In additional embodiments, the systems and methods disclosed furtherinclude a graph that is fully connected. Additional embodiments caninclude utilizing a random graph model to select a subset of individualsto connect using edges which can alleviate noise and over complexity.Some embodiments disclosed herein can include weighted edges on thegraph and labeling one or more of the individuals as positive ornegative. The individuals chosen as positive or negative labels can beexemplary good or bad professionals in their field.

In yet other embodiments consistent with the present disclosure, thesystem and methods can include labeling a first set of individuals ofthe plurality of individuals as exemplary wherein the first set ofindividuals includes at least one individual that is associated with asubset of features and wherein the subset of features correlate toqualities associated with exemplary individuals. In these embodimentsthe system and methods can further identify a second set of individualsof the plurality of individuals that are similar to at least oneindividual of the first set wherein the similarity is based on featuresassociated with the at least one individual and the second set ofindividuals. In these embodiments, the second set of individuals canalso be exemplary labels or labeled as exemplary.

In additional embodiments, the weighted or labeled nodes of the graphcan be treated as positive or negative point charges and the influenceexerted by the weighted nodes on the unweighted nodes can be calculatedby calculating the electrical potential associated with those nodes. Inthese embodiments, the graph can be analyzed using electrostaticmodeling and apply Poisson's equation, Laplace's equation, a Laplacianexponential diffusion kernel, a regularized Laplacian kernel, or a vonNeumann diffusion kernel to the graph.

In some embodiments, after weights are determined for all of the nodes,the individuals associated with those weights and the weights can beprovided for display on a graphical user interface, or for furtherprocessing and use by a client device or other components of the system.

The embodiments described herein can apply to many fields. Descriptionsand applications related to specific domains do not preclude theapplication of the described embodiments to other technologies offields.

FIG. 1 is a block diagram representing exemplary system 100 for datadriven analysis and modeling consistent with embodiments of the presentdisclosure. System 100 can include data input engine 110 that canfurther include data extractor 111, data transformer 112, and dataloader 113. Data input engine 110 can process data from data sources101-104. Data input engine 110 can be implemented using computing device200, described in more detail below in reference to FIG. 2. For example,data from data sources 101-104 can be obtained through I/O devices 230and/or network interface 218 of computing device 200. Further, the datacan be stored during processing in a suitable storage such as storage228 and/or system memory 221. Referring back to FIG. 1, data inputengine 110 can also interact with data storage 115. Data storage 115 canfurther be implemented on a computing device such as computing device200, described in detail below in FIG. 2, that stores data in storage228 and/or system memory 221. In some embodiments, data storage 115 canbe remote from computing device 200.

Referring back to FIG. 1, system 100 can include feature discoveryengine 120, label engine 130, graph visualization engine 135, semisupervised engine 140, graph construction engine 142, label propagationengine 144, evaluation engine 160, app engine 170, and dashboard engine180. System 100 can further include output terminals or displays 190,191, and 193. Similarly to data input engine 110, these variouscomponents can be implemented on a computing device such as computingdevice 200, can utilize storage 228 and/or system memory 221 for storingdata, and can utilize I/O device 230 or network interface 218 fortransmitting and/or receiving data, all described in more detail belowin reference to FIG. 2. Each of data input engine 110, data extractor111, data transformer 112, data loader 113, feature discovery engine120, label engine 130, graph visualization engine 135, semi-supervisedengine 140, graph construction engine 142, label propagation engine 144,evaluation engine 160, app engine 170, and dashboard engine 180 can be amodule, which is a packaged functional hardware unit designed for usewith other components or a part of a program that performs a particularfunction of related functions. Each of these modules can be implementedusing computing device 200 of FIG. 2. Each of these components isdescribed in more detail below. In some embodiments, the functionalityof system 100 can be split across multiple computing devices (e.g.,multiple devices similar to computing device 200) to allow fordistributed processing of the data. In these embodiments the differentcomponents can communicate over I/O device 230 or network interface 218of FIG. 2's computing device 200.

System 100 can be related to many different domains or fields of use.Descriptions of embodiments related to specific domains, such ashealthcare, is not intended to limit the disclosed embodiments to aspecific domain, and embodiments consistent with the present disclosurecan apply to any domain that utilizes predictive modeling based onavailable data.

Data input engine 110 is a module that can retrieve data from a varietyof data sources (e.g., data source 101, 102, 103, and 104) and processthe data so that it can be used with the remainder of system 100. Datainput engine 110 can further include data extractor 111, datatransformer 112, and data loader 113.

Data extractor 111 retrieves data from data sources 101, 102, 103, and104. Each of these data sources can represent a different type of datasource. For example, data source 101 can be a database. Data source 102can represent structured data. Data sources 103 and 104 can be flatfiles. Further, data sources 101-104 can contain overlapping orcompletely disparate data sets. In some embodiments, data source 101 cancontain individual information while data sources 102, 103, and 104contain various insurance claim and medical treatment data. For example,data source 101 can contain data structure 400, 500, and 600 of FIGS. 4,5, and 6. Data extractor 111 can interact with the various data sources,retrieve the relevant data, and provide that data to data transformer112.

Data transformer 112 can receive data from data extractor 111 andprocess the data into standard formats. In some embodiments, datatransformer 112 can normalize data such as dates. For example datasource 101 can store dates in day-month-year format while data source102 can store dates in year-month-day format. In this example, datatransformer 112 can modify the data provided through data extractor 111into a consistent date format. Accordingly, data transformer 112 caneffectively clean the data provided through data extractor 111 so thatall of the data, although originating from a variety of sources, has aconsistent format.

Moreover, data transformer 112 can extract additional data points fromthe data. For example, data transformer can process a date inyear-month-day format by extracting separate data fields for the year,the month, and the day. Data transformer can also perform other linearand non-linear transformations and extractions on categorical andnumerical data such as normalization and demeaning. Data transformer 112can provide the transformed and/or extracted data to data loader 113.

Data loader 113 can receive the normalized data from data transformer112. Data loader 113 can merge the data into varying formats dependingon the specific requirements of system 100 and store the data in anappropriate storage mechanism such as data storage 115. In someembodiments, data storage 115 can be data storage for a distributed dataprocessing system (e.g., Hadoop Distributed File System, Google FileSystem, ClusterFS, and/or OneFS). In some embodiments, data storage 115can be a relational database (described in more detail below). Inadditional embodiments data storage 115 can be a graph database (e.g.,Neo4j or Titan) Depending on the specific embodiment, data loader 113can optimize the data for storing and processing in data storage 115. Insome embodiments, data structures 400, 500, and 600 from FIGS. 4, 5, and6 (or versions thereof) can be stored by data loader 113 in data storage115.

Feature discovery engine 120 can process the data prepared by data inputengine 110 and stored in data storage 115. Feature discovery engine canretrieve data from data storage 115 that has been prepared by date inputengine 110. For example, data structures 400, 500, and 600 of FIGS. 4,5, and 6 can be suitable inputs to feature discovery engine 120.

As shown in FIG. 4, data structure 400 is an exemplary data structure,consistent with embodiments of the present disclosure. Data structure400 can store data records associated with professionals. While datastructure 400 is shown to store information related to physicians, it isappreciated that it can store information related to any profession.Data structure 400 can, for example, be a database, a flat file, datastored in memory (e.g., system memory 221), and/or data stored in anyother suitable storage mechanism (e.g., storage 228).

In some embodiments, data structure 400 can be a Relational DatabaseManagement System (RDBMS) (e.g., Oracle Database, Microsoft SQL Server,MySQL, PostgreSQL, and/or IBM DB2). An RDBMS can be designed toefficiently return data for an entire row, or record, in as fewoperations as possible. An RDBMS can store data by serializing each rowof data of data structure 400. For example, in an RDBMS, data associatedwith record 401 of FIG. 4 can be stored serially such that dataassociated with all categories of record 401 can be accessed in oneoperation. Moreover, an RDBMS can efficiently allow access of relatedrecords stored in disparate tables. For example, in an RDBMS, datastructure 400 of FIG. 4 and data structure 500 (described in more detailbelow) of FIG. 5 can be linked by a referential column. In this example,professional ID 580 of data structure 500 can directly relate toprofessional ID 410 of data structure 400. An RDBMS can allow for theefficient retrieval of all records in data structure 500 associated witha record of data structure 400 based on a common value for therespective professional ID fields (e.g., professional ID 580 of datastructure 500 and professional ID 410 of data structure 400).

In some embodiments, data structure 400 of FIG. 4 can be anon-relational database system (NRDBMS) (e.g., XML, Cassandra, CouchDB,MongoDB, Oracle NoSQL Database, FoundationDB, and/or Redis). Anon-relational database system can store data using a variety of datastructures such as, among others, a key-value store, a document store, agraph, and a tuple store. For example, a non-relational database using adocument store could combine all of the data associated with aparticular professional ID (e.g, professional ID 410 of data structure400 and professional ID 580 of data structure 500 in FIG. 5) into asingle document encoded using XML. In this example, the XML documentwould include the information stored in record 402 of data structure 400and record 505 of data structure 500 based on these records sharing thesame professional ID value.

Data structure 400 of FIG. 4 can include data records 401-405representing physicians in addition to countless additional records upto record 499. Data structure 400 can contain many thousands or millionsof records of data and is limited only by the physical constraints ofthe system upon which the data structure exists.

Data structure 400 can include categories of data representing aphysician. For example data structure 400 can include categoriesprofessional ID 410, gender 420, age 430, location 440, specialty 450,and affiliations 460. Data associated with data records 401-405 can bestored under each of these categories. For example, a physicianrepresented by data record 401 has a person ID of “1,” is male asrepresented by an “M” under gender 420, is 54 as listed under age 430,works in zip code “94403” as represented under location 440, specializesin cardiology as represented under specialty 450, and is affiliated withthe Palo Alto Medical Foundation (PAMF) as represented by affiliations460.

In some embodiments, data structure 400 can contain more or fewercategories for each data record. For example, data structure 400 caninclude additional categories of data such as certifications, education,publications, or any other category of data associated with aprofessional. Moreover, depending on the circumstances, data structure400 can contain domain specific data. For example, in a healthcarecontext, in addition to healthcare specific specialty 450 andaffiliations 460 data, data structure 400 can include insurance coverageinformation, practice or group name, teaching positions, or otherinformation related to a physician. Accordingly, data structure 400 isnot limited to only those categories shown in FIG. 4.

In some embodiments, data structure 400 contains categories that storesimilar data. For example, data structure 400 can include location 440that represents a business address zip code, while an additional“location” category (not shown) can be used to store a secondarybusiness zip code. In some embodiments, categories, such as location,can be stored in multiple normalized tables. For example, a separatetable representing physician locations could store all of the locationinformation for a physician in a separate data structure or, in thecontext of a relational database, a table, using multiple records. Thesedisparate data sets or tables can include referential categories thatcan be used to join the data.

Additionally, data structure 400 can include combination categories. Forexample, instead of only using location 440 to represent locationinformation, data structure 400, in some embodiments, includescategories for, among others, street address, state, city, and/orcountry. This data can be stored under one category or separatecategories that, together, represent a location.

Moreover, location 440 can store different types of data. In someembodiments, location 440 is a zip code. In other embodiments, location440 is a combination category as previously described. Location 440 canfurther include, geospatial coordinates, map coordinates, or any otherdata type that indicates location.

Similarly to location 440, other categories, such as age 430, specialty450, and affiliations 460, can include data in a variety of formats. Forexample, age 430 can be represented in years, in years and months, indays, or by a date of birth.

In some embodiments, data stored under a category can be a referenceinto another data set or data structure as is common in relational datasets. For example, specialty 450 and affiliations 460 can contain anidentifier that references a description stored in a separate data setor lookup table instead of containing text or another data type.

Additionally, as shown in FIG. 5, data structure 500 is an exemplarydata structure, consistent with embodiments of the present disclosure.Data structure 500 can store data records associated with events thatare further associated with specific individuals. Similarly to datastructure 400 described in FIG. 4, data structure 500 can, for example,be a database, a flat file, data stored in memory (e.g., system memory221 of computing device 200 from FIG. 2), an RDBMS, an NRDBMS, and/ordata stored in any other suitable storage mechanism (e.g., storage 228of computing device 200 from FIG. 2). Moreover, data structure 500 canbe implemented or stored computing device similar to computing device200 described in FIG. 2.

Data structure 500 can store information related to events. Datastructure 500 can include data records 501-506 representing dataassociated with specific events in addition to countless additionalrecords up to record 599. Data structure 500 can contain millions orbillions of records of data and is limited only by the physicalconstraints of the system upon which the data structure exists.

Data structure 500 can include categories of data. For example, datastructure 500 can include the categories event ID 510, person ID 520,cost 530, code 1 540, code 2 550, code 3 560, date 570, and professionalID 580. Data associated with data records 501-506 can be stored in eachrespective row of data structure 500 within one of these categories. Forexample, an event represented by data record 501 is associated with aperson ID 520 of “1,” has a cost 530 of “$8000,” has values of “409,”“10021,” and “R0076,” for code 1 540, code 2 550, and code 3 560,respectively, a date 570 of “1/1/3010,” and a professional ID 580 of“3.” In some embodiments multiple professional ID categories can beincluded in the data structure to indicate the involvement of multiplephysicians. In other embodiments, multiple professional ID categoriescan be included to indicate different roles. In a healthcare context,data structure 500 can include categories for a professional ID for areferring physician, rendering physician, and supervising physician.

Moreover, data structure 500 can include multiple data recordsassociated with the same individual or professional. For example, datarecords 501-503 all have a value of 1 for person ID 520. Moreover, datarecords 501-504 all have a value of 3 for professional ID 580. Thesevalues can refer to a person ID number or professional ID number storedin a separate data set. For example, professional ID 580 can refer toprofessional ID 410 of data structure 400 described in FIG. 4. In thisexample, data records 501-504 of data structure 500 can be associatedwith data record 403 of data structure 400. Moreover, data record 505 ofdata structure 500 can be associated with data record 402 of datastructure 400 and data record 506 of data structure 500 can beassociated with data record 405 of data structure 400 based on thevalues in professional ID 580 and professional ID 410 of data structure400 in FIG. 4.

In some embodiments, the data records in data structure 500 are allrelated to the same type of event or a specific domain. For example,data structure 500 can contain data records related to medical insuranceclaims. In these embodiments, data structure 500 includes additionalcategories that are specific to these types of events or domains, suchas categories for deductibles. Moreover, in these embodiments, existingcategories may contain information related to the domain of the data.For example, in embodiments where data structure 500 includes healthinsurance claim data, code 1 540, code 2 550, and code 3 560 canrepresent International Statistical Classification of Diseases andRelated Health Problems (ICD) codes, Current Procedural Terminology(CPT) codes, and Healthcare Common Procedure Coding System (HCPCS) codesrespectively. Additionally, these types of codes can representhierarchical data. Accordingly, a specific code in one of code 1 540,code 2 550, or code 3, 560 may imply additional codes or proceduresbased on the specific classification system in use. In a differentdomain, code 1 540, code 2 550, and code 3 560 can represent differentidentifying information for the events represented in data structure500.

Similarly to data structure 400, data structure 500 can include more orfewer categories for each data record depending on the domain and thesource of the data record. Additionally, as described in relation todata structure 400, some categories of data structure 500 can store datain different formats that represent the same concept, such as a date orcost. For example, date 570 can contain only a month and year, or cancontain month, day, and year. In a similar example, cost can containvalues in terms of United States Dollars or in terms of othercurrencies.

Additionally, as shown in FIG. 6, data structure 600 is an exemplarydata structure, consistent with embodiments of the present disclosure.Data structure 600 can store data records associated with events thatare further associated with specific individuals. Similarly to datastructure 400 and data structure 500 described in FIGS. 4 and 5, datastructure 600 can, for example, be a database, a flat file, data storedin memory (e.g., system memory 221 of computing device 200 from FIG. 2),an RDBMS, an NRDBMS, and/or data stored in any other suitable storagemechanism (e.g., storage 228 of computing device 200 from FIG. 2).Moreover, data structure 600 can be implemented or stored in a computingdevice similar to computing device 200 described in FIG. 2.

Data structure 600 can store information related to events associatedwith a product. For example, event could be the purchase of a product,or in the domain of healthcare, prescription information related to adrug. Data structure 600 can include data records 601-606 representingdata associated with a specific event in addition to countlessadditional records up to record 699. Data structure 600 can containmillions or billions of records of data and is limited only by thephysical constraints of the system upon which the data structure exists.

Data structure 600 can include categories of data. For example, datastructure 600 can include the categories event ID 610, product ID 620,person ID 630, cost 640, date 650, and professional ID 660. Dataassociated with data records 601-606 can be stored in each respectiverow of data structure 600 within one of these categories. For example,an event represented by data record 601 is associated with a product ID620 of “0573-0133,” person ID 630 of “1,” has a cost 640 of “$4,500,” adate 650 of “Jan. 1, 2010,” and a professional ID 680 of “5.” In thisexample, product ID 620 can be a reference to the ID for a drug listingin the National Drug Code (NDC) database, and data record 601 canrepresent a prescription for a medication, such as Advil®. Moreover,data structure 600 can include multiple data records associated with thesame individual or professional. For example, data records 601-603 allhave a value of “1” for person ID 630. Moreover, data records 601-604all have a value of 3 for professional ID 680. These values can refer toa person ID number or professional ID number stored in a separate dataset. For example, professional ID 680 can refer to professional ID 410of data structure 400 described in FIG. 4. In this example, data records601-604 of data structure 600 can be associated with data record 403 ofdata structure 400. Moreover, data record 605 of data structure 600 canbe associated with data record 402 of data structure 400 based on thevalues in professional ID 680 and professional ID 410 of data structure400 in FIG. 4.

In some embodiments, the data records in data structure 600 are allrelated to the same type of event or a specific domain. For example,data structure 600 can contain data records related to drug prescriptionclaims. In these embodiments, data structure 600 includes additionalcategories that are specific to these types of events or domains, suchas categories for deductibles. Moreover, in these embodiments, existingcategories may contain information related to the domain of the data.For example, in embodiments where data structure 600 includes drugprescription claim data, product ID 620 can represent National DrugCodes (NDC) that are part of the National Drug Code Directory.

Similarly to data structure 400 and data structure 500, data structure600 can include more or fewer categories for each data record dependingon the domain and the source of the data record. Additionally, asdescribed in relation to data structures 400 and 500, some categories ofdata structure 600 can store data in different formats that representthe same concept, such as a date or cost. For example, date 650 cancontain only a month and year, or can contain month, day, and year. In asimilar example, cost can contain values in terms of United StatesDollars or in terms of other currencies.

Referring back to FIG. 1, feature discovery engine 120 can process thedata from data storage 115. This data can be stored using datastructures such as data structures 400, 500 and 600, described above inrelation to FIGS. 4, 5, and 6. From this data, feature discovery engine120 can determine features that describe the data.

A feature can be data that is representative of other data. Features canbe determined based on the domain, data type of a category, or manyother factors associated with data stored in a data structure.Additionally, a feature can represent information about multiple datarecords in a data set or information about a single category in a datarecord. Moreover, multiple features can be produced to represent thesame data.

A feature can be based on the data type stored for a category. Acategory that stores real numbers, for example, can be represented by afeature generated using functions such as minimum, maximum, average, ormean across multiple data sets. For example, a feature representing themaximum cost charged by physician for a medical procedure can be basedon the cost 530 category of data structure 500 in FIG. 5. In thisexample, data records 501-504 represent medical procedures performed bythe same physician. A feature representing the maximum cost charged bythat physician can be calculated by comparing the cost values of“$8000,” “$2500,” “$100,” and “$1200” stored in data records 501-404 anddetermining that “$8000” is the maximum value. This type of feature canbe determined for only those records pertaining to the same physician orcan be determined across a data set representing claims for multiplephysicians.

One set of data points can produce multiple features related to thatdata. For example, in addition to calculating the maximum cost for datarecords 501-504 of FIG. 5, features representing the average cost,minimum cost, mean cost, or cost distribution can also be determinedfrom the same cost category of data records 501-504. In the case of adistribution, multiple features can be generated that represent thedifferent aspects of or summarize the distribution. For example, thedistribution of the cost stored in data records 401-403 can result infeatures that describe the skew, kurtosis, entropy among otherdistribution related measurements of the cost data.

In addition to features associated with real numbers, features can bebased on categorizations. Categorizations can include a count of datapoints, specific data indicators, most frequent types of data points, orsimilar features. In some embodiments, in relation to healthcare data,categories can include the most expensive claim, the count of claims,particular claims known to be indicators of a specific condition, forexample, a heart attack, a specific category of ICD or CPT codes, themost frequent code in the claims data, or many additionalcharacteristics of the claims data. Each of these categories can beestablished as a feature.

Moreover, features can be established based on dates. In some embodimentrelated to healthcare and claims data, features can include the durationof certain types of claims or treatments, the onset date of a particulartype of claim, or similar date data.

Features can also be based on data not directly included in the datarecords. In a healthcare context, for example, code 1 540, code 2 550,and code 3 560 can represent specific codes, such as ICD, CPT, or HCPCScodes that represent specific treatments. These codes can be part of alarger hierarchical system. For example, a code that represents thetreatment of high insulin levels may implicitly indicate treatment fordiabetes although only the code for high insulin is included in the datarecord. Because of the hierarchical nature of the coding system, featurediscovery engine 120 can determine that a claim for high insulinincludes both a feature for the treatment of high insulin as well as afeature representing the treatment of diabetes. In another example, datarecords can contain a reference, such as a National Provider Identifier(NPI), that identifies a provider. In this example, the providerinformation can be joined with the data records providing additionaldata and information for determining features. This sort of externaldata can be stored in, for example, data storage 115 of FIG. 1 andavailable to feature discovery engine 120. These examples anddescriptions of features are not exhaustive. Features can be any datadescriptive of the data stored in a record and feature discovery engine120 can generate a data structure to store the determined features.

As shown in FIG. 7 data structure 700, is an exemplary data structure,consistent with embodiments of the present disclosure. Data structure700 can use a representation of features related to professional createdby feature discovery engine 120. Similarly to data structure 400described in FIG. 4, data structure 500 described in FIG. 5, and datastructure 600 described in FIG. 6, data structure 700 can, for example,be a database, a flat file, data stored in memory (e.g., system memory221 of computing device 200), an RDBMS, an NRDBMS, and/or data stored inany other suitable storage mechanism (e.g., storage 228 of computingdevice 200). Moreover, data structure 700 can be implemented or storedon a system similar computing device 200 as described in FIG. 2.

Data structure 700 can store feature information related toprofessionals. Data structure 700 can include data records 701-705representing individuals in addition to countless additional recordsrepresented by records up to record 799. Data structure 700 can containmany millions or billions of records of data and is limited only by thephysical constraints of the system upon which the data structure exists.Moreover, data structure 700 can include many thousands of featurecategories in addition to feature categories Feature 1, Feature 2,Feature 3, Feature 4, and Feature 5.

Similarly to data structure 500 in FIG. 5 and data structure 600 in FIG.6, professional ID 710 of FIG. 7 can be a reference to data structure400 of FIG. 4. Accordingly data record 701 can represent data about thesame professional as data record 401 of data structure 400 based on theProfessional ID of each respective data structure. Moreover, as will bedemonstrated below, values associated with feature categories Feature 1through Feature 5 can be based on data contained in additional datastructures such as data structure 500 of FIG. 5 and data structure 600of FIG. 6. Thus, data structures 400, 500, 600 and 700 of FIGS. 3, 4, 5and 6, respectively, can all be linked based on the professional IDcategories 410, 580, 660 and 710, respectively. Moreover, each featurecategory, Feature 1 through Feature 5 can correspond directly tofeatures identified and/or calculated by feature discovery engine 120.

After a feature is established and/or calculated as described above(e.g., by feature discovery engine 120) the feature can be processedinto a binary value and stored in data structure 700. Data records701-706 can include this binary data associated with each featurecategory. For example, data record 701 includes a “5” value for Feature1, a “0” value for Feature 4 and a “1” value for Feature 2 and Feature3, and a “1.6” value for Feature 5. A zero value for a feature categorycan indicate that the individual referenced by professional ID 710 forthe data record does not have that particular feature while a one valuefor a feature category can indicate that the individual referenced byperson ID 710 does have that feature. As shown in record 701, differentdata types can be used for features. As shown features can includebinary data, real number data, integer data, as well as a variety ofother data types and is not limited to just those shown in datastructure 700.

For example, Feature 2 can represent a feature of “Female.” As shownabove, person ID 710 can be a reference to additional data structuressuch as data structure 400 described in FIG. 4. Data records 403 and 404of data structure 400 include a value of “F” for gender 420.Accordingly, because data records 703 and 704 can refer to data records403 and 404 based on having the same value for professional IDs 410 and710, data records 703 and 704 can contain a “1” value for the feature of“Female.” In this example, because an individual can only be male orfemale, data records 701, 702, and 705 represent individuals who aremale based on the zero value for Feature 2. In some embodiments, aseparate feature category can be used to represent a “Male” feature.

In another example in a healthcare context, Feature 4 can be a featurerepresenting “Physicians who have written more than one prescription.”Moreover, data structure 600 can represent prescription data. Becausedata structure 700 can be associated with data structure 600 based onthe values of professional ID 710 and 660, the data in data structure600 can be used to populate values for Feature 4 of data structure 700.As shown in FIG. 6, data records 601-604 are associated withProfessional ID “3” and data records 605 and 606 are associated withProfessional IDs “2” and “7,” respectively. Accordingly, because datarecords 601-604 of data structure 600 are all associated with aphysician having a professional ID of 3, that particular physician haswritten 4 prescriptions. Because Feature 4 of data structure is“physicians who have written more than one prescription,” data record703 can contain a “1” value to indicate that, based on the prescriptiondata in data structure 600, the physician referred to in data record 703has written more than one prescription.

Various other features can be created based on any available date. Manyof these features can be domain specific. For example, in a healthcarecontext, features can be used to indicate medical schools, residencies,hospital affiliations, board memberships, claims analytics, specialties,the number of patients treated, the specific diseases treated ortreatment codes used, the amount billed, the number of referrals ortimes referred, the physicians role for particular treatments (e.g., asa referring physician, rendering physician, or both), or any other typeof information that can be used to categorize or describe a physician.

Further features can include analytics of the various types of data.These analytics can further be broken down by category. For example, ifa claim data associated with a physician includes referrals, renderings,and both (e.g., a self-referral), individual analytics for the physiciancan be included for each of these roles. These various analytics, aswell as overall analytics can be expressed as various features in datastructure 700.

Additionally, feature discovery engine 120 can produce multiple binaryfeatures based on one or more specific non-binary features. For example,quantile binning or hashing techniques can be used to classifycategorical data. Data that represents a range or duration can berepresented by the quantile bin with which that range corresponds.

For example, in a healthcare context, claim data related to thetreatment of chest pain may indicate that different specificprofessionals treated chest pain by ordering different types of test. Inthis example, if the range of the number of tests ordered that arerepresented in the data set is between 0 and 100 tests, a binaryrepresentation of the number of tests feature can be obtained bysplitting the possible range into 4 groups of 25 tests each. Further, inthis example, each representation of the feature can include a featurecategory for each of the four groups with a “1” value for the specificnumber range that relates to the number of tests ordered by thatphysician for treatment of a patient's chest pain and a “0” value forall other numbers for that physician. For example, a physician whoordered 40 tests for chest pain could have a “0” for feature categoriesrepresenting number of tests ranges of 1-25 tests, 51-75 tests, and76-100 tests and a “1” value for the feature category representing 26-50tests. The number of bins used can be increased or decreased based onthe specific data type, the data represented, the specific domain, orother factors. In some embodiments, the same total number data could beprocessed using multiple bin sets. For example, total number data couldbe processed using a 4 bin set as well as processed using a 10 bin set.The binary output from both sets of processing can be stored for theindividual and included as part of the later analysis.

After processing the data, feature discovery engine 120 can producefeature data, which can be stored in data storage 215 for later analysisor passed directly to other components of the system. The feature dataincluded can be based on automated processes or can be based on apre-determined set of features.

The feature discovery engine 120 can provide the generated feature datato label engine 130. From the data set, label engine 130 can selectprofessionals as positive or negative examples of the members of theirprofession. In a healthcare context, label engine 130 can identify goodand bad physicians and use those identified physicians as labels. Thespecific criteria for determining good and bad is described in moredetail below and can be based on domain specific factors. In thefollowing discussion, the examples of using physician data are exemplaryonly, and the same technique can be used in many different domains.

Label engine 130 can analyze the feature data provided by featurediscovery engine 120. From this data, and based on characteristics ofthe specific domain, certain signal features can be used to indicateoutliers in both a positive and negative direction for the given domain.For example, in a healthcare context, physician labels can be createdfor good and bad doctors. Although good and bad can be subjectivedeterminations, certain features can be used to indicate the level ofquality of doctors.

Label engine 130 can include outlier detection engine 132. Outlierdetection engine 132 can discover outliers in the data set that areclearly positive or negative examples of the quality of doctors. Thesedeterminations can be made by a manual identification if the specificphysician. Additionally, certain defined characteristics can be anindication that a specific physician is an exemplary positive ornegative label. In some embodiments, outlier detection engine 132 is aseparate component from label engine 130.

In addition to outlier detection engine 132, label engine 130 can relyon the feature data to determine labels. For example, some of thefeature data may indicate that a particular physician produces a largenumber of Relative Value Units (“RVUs”). RVUs are a measure that is usedfor Medicare reimbursement. A high number of RVUs billed can indicatethat a physician is well compensated, which can further indicate highquality. These types of metrics can further be controlled based on otherfeatures or demographics. RVU measurements can be unhelpful whencomparing a general practice physician to a specialist but whencomparing two physicians in the same specialty and/or sub-specialty,RVUs can provide an indicator of quality. Additionally, features canindicate the amount that a physician publishes in their field. Activecommunity participation and scholarship in an area of specialty canfurther indicate the quality of the physician. Many other types offeatures can be used. In some embodiments, features indicating boardcertifications, group memberships, or similar accomplishments canindicate quality. Additional measures of physician performance, like thenumber of procedures performed, the type of procedures performed, andthe number of complications can further indicate quality.

Conversely, features can also indicate physicians that are consideredlower quality. For example, features can indicate the number of ethicalviolations, reprimands, malpractice proceedings, patient complaints, orsimilar negative actions taken against a physician. This type of featuremay indicate physicians considered to be of lower quality. Additionalfeatures could include statistics like patient turnover. Similarly tothe positive features, these statistics can be controlled based onspecialty type because some specialties or types of physicians maynaturally have higher patient turnover. Similarly to considering highlevels of publishing as a positive feature, low levels of publishing canbe considered a negative feature. This can be especially true if thelevel of publishing is compared to the averages for physicians orphysicians in that particular specialty. Moreover, physician behaviorand claim information can further indicate quality level. For example,if the over prescription of certain tests for a particularly conditionindicates lower quality care, features indicating the overuse of thatparticularly test can be used to identify physicians of lower quality.

Additionally, multiple sets of features can be used to classifyprofessionals. Referring again to physicians, while metrics, such asattending a respected medical school or a securing a selectivefellowship, can help identify high quality physicians, there arepotentially many other physicians who are high quality but would nothave these features. These physicians, however, may be active in thecommunity or account for a high level of RVUs. By using multiple sets offeatures, different types of physicians can be identified. For example,a particular doctor could hold a record for the highest number ofcomplex coronary interventions performed annually, hold a record for thehighest angioplasty success rate in New York, and have her own Wikipediapage, but she did not attend a United States medical school. Traditionalmethods for determining quality that highly favor medical school wouldnot consider that doctor a high quality physician although based on herpractice history she would likely be considered a high qualityphysician. Accordingly, using features that represent different types ofdata can lead to better identification of physicians as high or lowquality and whose designations can be based on different criteria.

In some embodiments, multiple features represent the same idea. Forexample, experience can be represented by features for the number ofprocedures performed and also years of experience. In these embodiments,number of procedures performed can be a better signal of high or lowquality even though both features are a measure of experience.

The specific features and combination of features described above areexemplary. Any features produced by feature discover engine 120 can beused to determine both good and bad exemplary professionals. As moredata is considered and modeled, system 100 can adjust the features usedbased on evaluation of the system's output. This evaluation is discussedin more detail below.

After an initial set of high quality and low quality professionals areidentified, label engine 130 can designate these professionals aslabels. Label engine 130 can then proceed to expand the labels to otherprofessionals in the data set. The initial goal of assigning labels isto identify a core set of high and low quality professionals. Varioustechniques can then be used to expand the labels to other professionalsin the data set to allow for a sufficient amount of data for the nextsteps in the process implemented by system 100.

Label engine 130 can use the initial set of identified professionals andfurther identify nearest neighbors. By treating the feature list as avector representing each physician, various statistical analysisapproaches can be used to find the nearest neighbors to the alreadyidentified professionals. The number of additional neighbors used candepend on the number of professionals initially identified by labelengine 130.

In some embodiments, label engine 130 can use locality sensitive hashingto find nearest neighbors. This approach can provide increases inprocessing feed. Additional embodiments can randomly select subsets ofneighbors. In yet another embodiment, a brute-force approach can be usedto find nearest neighbors. In these embodiments, the distances of allpairwise neighbors are computed. These embodiments can provide the mostaccurate results but at a significant computational complexity.

Semi-supervised engine 140 can include components that implementsemi-supervised learning approaches for analyzing the available dataset. In particular, semi-supervised engine 140 can consist of graphconstruction engine 142 and label propagation engine 144. The inclusionof graph construction engine 142 and label propagation engine 144 insemi-supervised engine 140 is only exemplary. In some embodiments thesemodules are implemented or represented as separate and distinctcomponents.

Graph construction engine 142 can generate a graph representation of theprofessionals represented in the feature data. Graph construction engine142 can combine the feature data with the labels determined by labelengine 130 to create a connected graph. Graph construction engine 142can build a graph based on similarities among the professionals in thefeature data and place the appropriate labels on that graph.

As shown in FIG. 8, graph 800 can represent a graph consistent withembodiments of the present disclosure. Graph 800 can be a graphgenerated by graph construction engine 142. The structure of the graphcan be based on the feature data (e.g., feature data similar to thatshown in data structure 700 of FIG. 7). Each node (e.g., nodes 810, 820,and 830) can represent a professional that exists in the feature data.Each edge (e.g., edges 815) can represent a similarity between the nodesthe edge connects.

Although FIG. 8 shows a visual representation of graph 800 that caninclude visual elements to represent the nodes, edges, and otherinformation associated with the graph, it is appreciated that this isonly one representation of graph 800. Graph 800 could also berepresented as a list, raw data, or some other representation of thedata structure that defines the graph structure, wherein nodes of thegraph could be represented as entries (e.g., within the list, raw data,or data structure) and the edges could be represented as links betweenthe entries (or some other indicator associating multiple entries havingsimilarities). As described herein, a graph (e.g., graph 800)encompasses all of these various representations.

Node 820 can represent a professional that is a positive label in thegraph structure. A positive label can include a positive classificationof a professional. For example a positive label can be applied to aprofessional considered to be at the top of his or her profession.Depending on the domain and system used to rank professionals, apositive label can be applied to a professional considered to be a 10out of 10, an A+, a tier 1 professional, or some other relativeclassification that indicates a professional at the peak of their field.Similarly Node 830 can represent a professional that is a negative labelin the data set. Negative labels can represent those professionalsidentified at the bottom of their field. Example ratings can include a 0out of 10, an F, a bottom of tier, or some other relative classificationof a professional that indicates a professional at the bottom of theirfield. In creating graph 800, there is a tendency that nodes clusteredaround positive or negative labels will exhibit similar characteristics.

Referring back to FIG. 1, graph construction engine 142 can generategraph 800 based on the feature data. Graph 800 can be used to furtheranalyze various interactions among the professionals. Graph constructionengine 142 can weight edges 815 based on the similarity between theconnected professionals. Graph construction engine 142 can usetechniques such as, among others, cosine similarity, Gaussian KernelSimilarity, Euclidian distance similarity, Jaccard similarity, andManhatten similarity.

In addition to weighting the edges (e.g., edges 815 of graph 800), graphconstruction engine 142 can determine which edges should be included inthe graph. By choosing which features define the similarity of theprofessionals in the feature data (e.g., feature data in data structure700) represented as nodes (e.g., nodes 810, 820, and 830), graphconstruction engine 142 can control the number edges in graph 800. Thenumber of edges can be controlled by the threshold that is used by graphconstruction engine 142 when constructing the graph. If the graph isconstructed using k-nearest neighbors, than each node of graph 800 canbe connected to the k nodes that are determined to be closest. In someother embodiments, the edges can be constructed by placing edges betweennodes that are within a constant value of each other using apredetermined metric. If there are too many edges, the graph will be toonoisy and be more difficult to analyze. If there are too few edges, theconnections between nodes will not provide enough information to makeaccurate comparisons among the professionals represented by the nodes.Moreover, graph construction engine 142 can retain edges associated withfeature similarity that is most relevant to classify the professionalsrepresented by the nodes as high or low quality.

As an example of the effect of noise, too many data points can hindereffective analysis. As shown in FIG. 9, clusters of nodes can exist inthe data being generated by graph construction engine 142. For example,negative cluster 910 can represent a large cluster of nodes that shouldall be associated with negative labels and positive cluster 920 canrepresent a large cluster of nodes that should all be associated withpositive labels. Negative labels can be represented by negative nodes913 in negative cluster 910, and positive labels can be represented bypositive nodes 923 in positive cluster 920 respectively. In someembodiments, however, positive nodes that are near negative clusters andnegative nodes that are near positive clusters can be mislabeled. Forexample, positive nodes 927 can, in some cases, be labeled as negativenodes due to their proximity to cluster 910. Similarly, negative nodes917 can mistakenly be labeled as positive nodes due to their proximityto cluster 920. These labels, which are noise introduced through dataprocessing, can cause portions of negative cluster to be erroneouslypositive. Similarly, mislabeled positive nodes 927 can have the sameeffect on cluster 920. Accordingly, over analysis and noise can havedetrimental effects. By utilizing methods to choose appropriate edgesand labels for the graph creation and through the evaluation processdescribed below noise can be controlled while still providing enoughdata to have a fully connected graph.

Referring back to FIGS. 1 and 8, different methods exist for choosingappropriate edges and help alleviate both computational complexity andthe effects of noise in the system. One approach is to find thek-nearest neighbors to every physician. Various methods for finding thek-nearest neighbors can be used. A brute force approach can be effectivebut is not always the most efficient approach to choosing relevant edgesto include in graph 800. Conversely, other methods of choosing k-nearestneighbors can be more efficient but not as accurate as a brute forceapproach. In some embodiments, graph construction engine 142 uses alocality sensitive hashing to determine the nearest neighbors to eachprofessional. Graph construction engine 142 can also randomly choose kneighbors from the set of nearest neighbors to each professional.Additional methods of choosing which neighbors for each professionalshould be represented on the graph exist and can be effective algorithmsfor placing edges 815 on graph 800.

Whichever algorithm is used, graph construction engine 142 can adjustthe number of edges provided by any of the approaches to provide a fullyconnected graph 800. In determining how many connections are necessary,graph construction engine can utilize the Erdős-Rényi model. This modelcan be used to calculate the number of nearest neighbors for eachprofessional that need to be placed on graph 800 as edges 815 to ensurewith relative certainty that the graph of all of the professionalsconstructed from the feature data, represented by nodes 810, 820, and830 in graph 800, is fully connected.

As graph 800 is constructed by graph construction engine 142, graphconstruction engine can place the appropriate labels, identified bylabel engine 130, on graph 800. For example, node 820 can represent aprofessional identified as a positive label by label engine 130 and node830 can represent a professional identified as a negative label by labelengine 130. These labels, combined with the graph generated by graphconstruction engine 142, can then be used for further analysis of thenon-labeled professionals (e.g., professionals represented by nodes810).

As described above, graph construction engine 142 can utilize a varietyof techniques to efficiently and effectively analyze the feature dataprovided by feature discovery engine 120 and the labels generated bylabel engine 130. In using these different techniques, system 100 andgraph construction engine 142, can drastically reduce the complexity ofthe computations necessary to generate graph 800. This reduction incomputational complexity can provide reductions in necessary CPU,memory, and computing power allowing for more efficient analysis onlarge data sets.

As shown in FIG. 1, graph construction engine 142 can also output graph800 and other data to graph visualization engine 135. Graphvisualization engine 135 can process the data associated with a graph(e.g., graph 800) and provide a visual representation of the graph. Forexample, a visual representation of the graph be similar to therepresentation of graph 800 in FIG. 8 that includes circles to representnodes (e.g., nodes 810, 820, and 830) and lines to represent edges(e.g., edges 815) connecting the nodes. Other representations caninclude a chart, a raw data display, or a textual description of thegraph. The visual representation of the graph can be provided to display193. Display 193 can be, for example, display device 224 of device 200,described below in reference to FIG. 2, or display 306 of client device300 described below in reference to FIG. 3. In some embodiments, bothgraph visualization engine 135 and display 193 are part of the samedevice (e.g., device 200 of FIG. 2 or client device 300 of FIG. 3). Inthese embodiments, graph visualization engine can directly connect tosystem 100 or can be connected to system 100 over a network or othercommunication systems. This connection can be provided by, for example,network interface 218 or I/O devices 230 of FIG. 2 and communicationssubsystem 304, short-range wireless communications 326, and data port318 of FIG. 3. In other embodiments, system 100 can include graphvisualization engine 135, and graph visualization engine 135 can providea visual representation to display 193 using a network or some othercommunication link. Moreover, display 193, or components connected todisplay 193, can accept user input and provide that input to graphvisualization engine 135. For example, user input can be captured by I/Odevices 230 or network interface 218 of device 200 in FIG. 2 or inputdevices 308, short-range wireless communications 326, and communicationssubsystem 304 of client device 300 in FIG. 3.

After graph construction engine 142 generates a graph (e.g., graph 800of FIG. 8) that represents the feature data (e.g., data structure 700 ofFIG. 7) that includes labels identified by label engine 130, labelpropagation engine 144 can begin analyzing the graph structure bypropagating positive and negative labels throughout the nodes of thegraph.

Different methods exist for propagating labels through the graph basedon the known labels. In some embodiments propagation can be achievedusing various graph kernel algorithms and diffusion algorithms. Othergraph modeling methods can be used to propagate the labels.

In some embodiments, the label propagation engine 144 treats thepositive and negative labels as positive and negative charges on thegraph. The positive labels and negative labels (e.g., nodes 820 and 830of graph 800 in FIG. 8) can represent boundary conditions. Labelpropagation engine 144 can then use Laplace's equation on the graph toidentify the charge potential for each node in the graph based on theboundary conditions. In using this equation on graph 800, labelpropagation engine 144 can determine the relative rank of the variousnodes in the graph based on the initial point charges.

Similarly, in some embodiments, the positive and negative labels can betreated as Coulomb potentials for use with Poisson's equation on thegraph. As described above, the resulting potential of the non-labelednodes (e.g., nodes 810 of graph 800) can be associated with a relativeranking from high quality to low quality based on the effect of thelabeled nodes (e.g., nodes 820 or 830). Because each node is mapped to aprofessional represented in the feature data (e.g., data structure 700of FIG. 7), the calculated Coulomb potential from label propagationengine 144 can be used to rank the professionals. By using electrostaticequations, label propagation engine 144 can model the effects of thepositive and negative labels as they spread to distant portions of thegraph in ways that are not apparent through visual inspection, manualinspection, or other analysis.

After analyzing the graph (e.g., graph 800), label propagation engine144 can provide a ranking of the nodes, and by their representation, theprofessionals based on the calculated values for each node. This rankingcan be provided to graph visualization engine 135 and can also beprovided to app engine 170. Similarly to graph visualization engine 135,app engine 170 can provide additional output to display 190. The outputcan include a visual representation of the updated graph (e.g., graph800), a chart representing the graph or relative rankings of the nodes,or other textual and/or graphical information representing the relativerankings of the nodes and professionals. Display 190 can be, forexample, display device 224 of device 200, described below in referenceto FIG. 2, or display 306 of client device 300 described below inreference to FIG. 3. In some embodiments, app engine 170 and display 190are part of the same device (e.g., device 200 of FIG. 2 or client device300 of FIG. 3). In these embodiments, graph visualization engine candirectly connect to system 100 or can be connected to system 100 over anetwork or other communication system. This connection can be providedby, for example, network interface 218 or I/O devices 230 of FIG. 2 andcommunications subsystem 304, short-range wireless communications 326,and data port 318 of FIG. 3. In other embodiments, system 100 caninclude graph visualization engine 135, and graph visualization engine135 can provide a visual representation to display 190 using a networkor some other communication link. Moreover, display 190, or componentsconnected to display 190, can accept user input and provide that inputto app engine 170. For example, user input can be captured by I/Odevices 230 or network interface 218 of device 200 in FIG. 2 or inputdevices 308, short-range wireless communications 326 communicationssubsystem 304 of client device 300 in FIG. 3.

App engine 170 can be used to provide information about the ranking andclassification of professionals based on their relative ranking score bylabel propagation engine 144. In some embodiments, app engine 170 doesnot directly display the output of label propagation engine 144, but,rather, is used to generate a graphical user interface capable ofinterpreting the output and displaying that output for use. In otherembodiments, the graphical user interface can display the output ofpropagation engine 144 directly.

In addition to app engine 170 and graph visualization engine 135, theoutput of label propagation engine 144 can be provided to evaluationengine 160. Evaluation engine 160 can evaluate the results of labelpropagation engine 144 to determine the effectiveness of the analysisand determinations made by system 100. Various methods for this analysisexist. In some embodiments, evaluation engine 160 uses a DiscountedCumulative Gain (DCG) algorithm to evaluate the rankings produced bylabel propagation engine 144.

Additional input sources and training data, such as customer or, in ahealthcare context, patient feedback can be used to evaluate therelevance of the produced rankings. In some embodiments, Rank BiasedPrecision (“RBP”) can allow the evaluation of the overall quality of arank of professionals. RBP can conceptualize a user descending down theranked list using a behavioral model that is controlled by a persistenceparameter. The RBP value can depend on a set of graded relevancejudgments, which are numerical scores assigned to a small number ofprofessionals. The higher the value of the graded relevance, the largerthe contribution to the utility function. In some embodiments, MonteCarlo simulations can further be used to estimate confidence intervals

Evaluation engine 160 can provide information and output to dashboardengine 180. Dashboard engine 180 can format the data and receive inputthat can be used to configure system 100 and adjust the variouscomponents of system 100. Similarly to app engine 170 and graphvisualization engine 135, dashboard engine 180 can provide additionaloutput to display 191. The output can include a visual representation ofthe updated graph (e.g., graph 800), a chart representing the graph orrelative rankings of the nodes, or other textual and/or graphicalinformation representing the relative rankings of the nodes andprofessionals. Display 191 can be, for example, display device 224 ofdevice 200, described below in reference to FIG. 2, or display 306 ofclient device 300 described below in reference to FIG. 3. In someembodiments, app engine 170 and display 191 are part of the same device(e.g., device 200 of FIG. 2 or client device 300 of FIG. 3). In theseembodiments, graph visualization engine can directly connect to system100 or can be connected to system 100 over a network or othercommunication system. This connection can be provided by, for example,network interface 218 or I/O devices 230 of FIG. 2 and communicationssubsystem 304, short-range wireless communications 326, and data port318 of FIG. 3. In other embodiments, system 100 can include dashboardengine 180, and dashboard engine 180 can provide a visual representationin the form of a graphical user interface to display 191 using a networkor some other communication link. Moreover, display 191, can accept userinput and provide that input to dashboard engine 180. For example, userinput can be captured by I/O devices 230 or network interface 218 ofdevice 200 in FIG. 2 or input devices 308, short-range wirelesscommunications 326 communications subsystem 304 of client device 300 inFIG. 3.

FIG. 2 is a block diagram of an exemplary computing device 200,consistent with embodiments of the present disclosure. In someembodiments, computing device 200 can be a specialized server providingthe functionality described herein. In some embodiments, system 100 isimplemented using computing device 200 or multiple computing devices 200operating in parallel. Further, computing device 200 can be a seconddevice providing the functionality described herein or receivinginformation from a server to provide at least some of that informationfor display. Moreover, computing device 200 can be an additional deviceor devices that store and/or provide data consistent with embodiments ofthe present disclosure.

Computing device 200 can include one or more central processing units(CPUs) 220 and system memory 221. Computing device 200 can also includeone or more graphics processing units (GPUs) 225 and graphic memory 226.CPUs 220 can be single or multiple microprocessors, field-programmablegate arrays, or digital signal processors capable of executing sets ofinstructions stored in a memory (e.g., system memory 221), a cache, or aregister. CPUs 220 can contain one or more registers for storingvariable types of data including, inter alia, data, instructions,floating point values, conditional values, memory addresses forlocations in memory (e.g., system memory 221 or graphic memory 226),pointers and counters. CPU registers can include special purposeregisters used to store data associated with executing instructions suchas an instruction pointer, instruction counter, and/or memory stackpointer. System memory 221 can include a tangible and/or non-transitorycomputer-readable medium, such as a flexible disk, a hard disk, acompact disk read-only memory (CD-ROM), magneto-optical (MO) drive,digital versatile disk random-access memory (DVD-RAM), a solid-statedisk (SSD), a flash drive and/or flash memory, processor cache, memoryregister, or a semiconductor memory. System memory 221 can be one ormore memory chips capable of storing data and allowing direct access byCPUs 220. System memory 221 can be any type of random access memory(RAM), or other available memory chip capable of operating as describedherein.

CPUs 220 can communicate with system memory 221 via a system interface250, sometimes referred to as a bus. GPUs 225 can be any type ofspecialized circuitry that can manipulate and alter memory (e.g.,graphic memory 226) to provide and/or accelerate the creation of images.GPUs 225 can store images in a frame buffer for output to a displaydevice such as display device 224. GPUs 225 can have a highly parallelstructure optimized for processing large, parallel blocks of graphicaldata more efficiently than general purpose CPUs 220. Furthermore, thefunctionality of GPUs 225 can be included in a chipset of a specialpurpose processing unit or a co-processor.

CPUs 220 can execute programming instructions stored in system memory221 or other memory, operate on data stored in memory (e.g., systemmemory 221) and communicate with GPUs 225 through the system interface250, which bridges communication between the various components ofcomputing device 200. In some embodiments, CPUs 220, GPUs 225, systeminterface 250, or any combination thereof, are integrated into a singlechipset or processing unit. GPUs 225 can execute sets of instructionsstored in memory (e.g., system memory 221), to manipulate graphical datastored in system memory 221 or graphic memory 226. For example, CPUs 220can provide instructions to GPUs 225, and GPUs 225 can process theinstructions to render graphics data stored in the graphic memory 226.Graphic memory 226 can be any memory space accessible by GPUs 225,including local memory, system memory, on-chip memories, and hard disk.GPUs 225 can enable displaying of graphical data stored in graphicmemory 226 on display device 224.

Computing device 200 can include display device 224 and input/output(I/O) devices 230 (e.g., a keyboard, a mouse, or a pointing device)connected to I/O controller 223. I/O controller 223 can communicate withthe other components of computing device 200 via system interface 250.It is appreciated that CPUs 220 can also communicate with system memory221 and other devices in manners other than through system interface250, such as through serial communication or direct point-to-pointcommunication. Similarly, GPUs 225 can communicate with graphic memory226 and other devices in ways other than system interface 250. Inaddition to receiving input, CPUs 220 can provide output via I/O devices230 (e.g., through a printer, speakers, or other output devices).

Furthermore, computing device 200 can include a network interface 218 tointerface to a LAN, WAN, MAN, or the Internet through a variety ofconnections including, but not limited to, standard telephone lines, LANor WAN links (e.g., 802.21, T1, T3, 56 kb, X.25), broadband connections(e.g., ISDN, Frame Relay, ATM), wireless connections, or somecombination of any or all of the above. Network interface 218 cancomprise a built-in network adapter, network interface card, PCMCIAnetwork card, card bus network adapter, wireless network adapter, USBnetwork adapter, modem or any other device suitable for interfacingcomputing device 200 to any type of network capable of communication andperforming the operations described herein.

FIG. 3 is a simplified block diagram illustrating an example electronicdevice 300. In some embodiments, electronic device 300 can include acommunication device having two-way or one-to-many data communicationcapabilities, audio communication capabilities, and/or videocommunication capabilities, and the capability to communicate with othercomputer systems, for example, via the Internet. Depending on thefunctionality provided by electronic device 300, in various embodiments,electronic device 300 can be a handheld device, a multiple-modecommunication device configured for both data and voice communication, asmartphone, a mobile telephone, a laptop, a computer wired to thenetwork, a netbook, a gaming console, a tablet, a smart watch, or a PDAenabled for wireless communication.

Electronic device 300 can include a case (not shown) housing componentof electronic device 300. The internal components of electronic device300 can, for example, be constructed on a printed circuit board (PCB).The description of electronic device 300 herein mentions a number ofspecific components and subsystems. Although these components andsubsystems can be realized as discrete elements, the functions of thecomponents and subsystems can also be realized by integrating,combining, or packaging one or more elements in any suitable fashion.

Electronic device 300 can include a controller comprising at least oneprocessor 302 (such as a microprocessor), which controls the overalloperation of electronic device 300. Processor 302 can be one or moremicroprocessors, field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs), digital signalprocessors (DSPs), or any combination thereof capable of executingparticular sets of instructions. Processor 302 can interact with devicesubsystems such as a communication subsystem 304 for exchanging radiofrequency signals with a wireless network to perform communicationfunctions.

Processor 302 can also interact with additional device subsystemsincluding a communication subsystem 304, a display 306 (e.g., a liquidcrystal display (LCD) screen, a touch-screen display, or any otherappropriate display), input devices 308 (e.g., a keyboard, a stylus, orcontrol buttons), a persistent memory 310, a random access memory (RAM)312, a read only memory (ROM) 314, auxiliary input/output (I/O)subsystems 316, a data port 318 (e.g., a conventional serial data port,a Universal Serial Bus (USB) data port, a 30-pin data port, a Lightningdata port, or a High-Definition Multimedia Interface (HDMI) data port),a speaker 320, a microphone 322, camera 324, a short-range wirelesscommunications subsystem 326 (which can employ any appropriate wireless(e.g., RF), optical, or other short range communications technology (forexample, Bluetooth or NFC)), and other device subsystems generallydesignated as 328. Some of the subsystems shown in FIG. 3 performcommunication-related functions, whereas other subsystems can provide“resident” or on-device functions.

Communication subsystem 304 includes one or more communication systemsfor communicating with a network to enable communication with socialnetworking services 104A-C and any external devices (e.g., a server, notshown). The particular design of communication subsystem 304 depends onthe wireless network in which electronic device 300 is intended tooperate. Electronic device 300 can send and receive communicationsignals over the wireless network after the required networkregistration or activation procedures have been completed.

In some embodiments, display 306 can be a touch-screen display. Thetouch-screen display can be constructed using a touch-sensitive inputsurface, which is coupled to an electronic controller and which overlaysthe visible element of display 306. The touch-sensitive overlay and theelectronic controller provide a touch-sensitive input device andprocessor 302 interacts with the touch-sensitive overlay via theelectronic controller.

Camera 324 can be a CMOS camera, a CCD camera, or any other type ofcamera capable of capturing and outputting compressed or uncompressedimage data such as still images or video image data. In some embodimentselectronic device 300 can include more than one camera, allowing theuser to switch, during a video conference call, from one camera toanother, or to overlay image data captured by one camera on top of imagedata captured by another camera. Image data output from camera 324 canbe stored in, for example, an image buffer, which can be a temporarybuffer residing in RAM 312, or a permanent buffer residing in ROM 314 orpersistent memory 310. The image buffer can be, for example, a first-infirst-out (FIFO) buffer.

Short-range wireless communications subsystem 326 is an additionaloptional component that provides for communication between electronicdevice 300 and different systems or devices, which need not necessarilybe similar devices. For example, short-range wireless communicationssubsystem 326 can include an infrared device and associated circuits andcomponents, or a wireless bus protocol compliant communication devicesuch as a Bluetooth® communication module to provide for communicationwith similarly-enabled systems and devices.

Processor 302 can be one or more processors that operate under storedprogram control and executes software modules 330 stored in atangibly-embodied non-transitory computer-readable storage medium suchas persistent memory 310, which can be a register memory, a processorcache, a Random Access Memory (RAM), a flexible disk, a hard disk, aCD-ROM (compact disk-read only memory), and MO (magneto-optical), aDVD-ROM (digital versatile disk-read only memory), a DVD RAM (digitalversatile disk-random access memory), or other semiconductor memories.

Software modules 330 can also be stored in a computer-readable storagemedium such as ROM 314, or any appropriate persistent memory technology,including EEPROM, EAROM, FLASH. These computer-readable storage mediumsstore computer-readable instructions for execution by processor 302 toperform a variety of functions on electronic device 300. Alternatively,functions and methods can also be implemented in hardware components orcombinations of hardware and software such as, for example, ASICs and/orspecial purpose computers.

Software modules 330 can include operating system software 332, used tocontrol operation of electronic device 300. Additionally, softwaremodules 330 can include software applications 334 for providingadditional functionality to electronic device 300. For example, softwareapplications 334 can include applications designed to interface withsystems like system 100 above (e.g., software applications 334 caninclude implementations of app engine 170, dashboard engine 180, andgraph visualization engine 135 described above in reference to FIG. 1).

Software applications 334 can also include a range of applications,including, for example, an e-mail messaging application, an addressbook, a notepad application, an Internet browser application, a voicecommunication (i.e., telephony or Voice over Internet Protocol (VoW))application, a mapping application, a media player application, ahealth-related application, a benefits-related application, etc. Each ofsoftware applications 334 can include layout information defining theplacement of particular fields and graphic elements (for example, textfields, input fields, icons, etc.) in the user interface (e.g., userinterfaces 300 shown in FIG. 3) according to that correspondingapplication.

Operating system software 332 can provide a number of applicationprotocol interfaces (APIs) providing an interface for communicatingbetween the various subsystems and services of electronic device 300,and software applications 334. For example, operating system software332 provides a user interface API to any application that needs tocreate user interfaces for display on electronic device 300. Accessingthe user interface API can provide the application with thefunctionality to create and manage screen windows and user interfacecontrols, such as text boxes, buttons, and scrollbars; receive mouse andkeyboard input; and other functionality intended for display on display306. Furthermore, a camera service API can allow a video communicationapplication to access camera 324 for purposes of capturing image data(such as an image or video data that can be shared using the socialnetworking services).

In some embodiments, persistent memory 310 stores data 336, includingdata specific to a user of electronic device 300, such as information ofuser accounts. Persistent memory 310 can also store data relating tothose (e.g., contents, notifications, and messages) obtained from socialnetworking services, data to be shared using the social networkingservices, or search results. Persistent memory 310 can further storedata relating to various applications with preferences of the particularuser of, for example, electronic device 300. In some embodiments,persistent memory 310 can store data 336 linking a user's data with aparticular field of data in an application, such as for automaticallyentering a user's name into a username textbox on an applicationexecuting on electronic device 300. Furthermore, in various embodiments,data 336 can also include service data comprising information requiredby electronic device 300 to establish and maintain communication with anetwork.

In some embodiments, auxiliary input/output (I/O) subsystems 316comprise an external communication link or interface, for example, anEthernet connection. In some embodiments, auxiliary I/O subsystems 316can further comprise one or more input devices, including a pointing ornavigational tool such as a stylus, a clickable trackball or scrollwheel or thumbwheel, or a human finger; and one or more output devices,including a mechanical transducer such as a vibrator for providingvibratory notifications in response to various events on electronicdevice 300 (for example, receipt of a notification or a message or anincoming phone call), or for other purposes such as haptic feedback(touch feedback); or any combination thereof.

In some embodiments, electronic device 300 can also include one or moreremovable memory modules 338 (e.g., FLASH memory) and a memory interface340. Removable memory module 338 can store information used to identifyor authenticate a user or the user's account to a wireless network. Forexample, in conjunction with certain types of wireless networks,including GSM and successor networks, removable memory module 338 isreferred to as a Subscriber Identity Module (SIM). Memory module 338 canbe inserted in or coupled to memory module interface 340 of electronicdevice 300 in order to operate in conjunction with the wireless network.

Electronic device 300 can also include a battery 342, which furnishesenergy for operating electronic device 300. Battery 342 can be coupledto the electrical circuitry of electronic device 300 through a batteryinterface 344, which can manage such functions as charging battery 342from an external power source (not shown) and the distribution of energyto various loads within or coupled to electronic device 300.

A set of applications that control basic device operations, includingdata and possibly voice communication applications, can be installed onelectronic device 300 during or after manufacture. Additionalapplications or upgrades to operating system software 332 or softwareapplications 334 can also be loaded onto electronic device 300 through awireless network, auxiliary I/O subsystem 316, data port 318,short-range wireless communication subsystem 326, or other suitablesubsystem such as 328. The downloaded programs or code modules can bepermanently installed, for example, written into the persistent memory310, or written into and executed from RAM 312 for execution byprocessor 302 at runtime.

Electronic device 300 can provide three principal modes ofcommunication: a data communication mode, a voice communication mode,and a video communication mode. In the data communication mode, areceived data signal such as a text message, an e-mail message, Web pagedownload, VOID data, or an image file are processed by communicationsubsystem 304 and input to processor 302 for further processing. Forexample, a downloaded Web page can be further processed by a browserapplication, or data obtained from social networking services can beprocessed by a unified social networking application and output todisplay 306. A user of electronic device 300 can also compose dataitems, such as contents for sharing using social networking services,e-mail messages, for example, using the input devices, such as auxiliaryI/O subsystem 316, in conjunction with display 306. These composed itemscan be transmitted through communication subsystem 304 over a wirelessnetwork. In the voice communication mode, electronic device 300 providestelephony functions and operates as a typical cellular phone. In thevideo communication mode, electronic device 300 provides video telephonyfunctions and operates as a video teleconference terminal. In the videocommunication mode, electronic device 300 utilizes one or more cameras(such as camera 324) to capture video for the video teleconference.

FIG. 10 is a flowchart of an exemplary method 1000 for data drivenanalysis, modeling, and semi-supervised machine learning for qualitativeand quantitative determinations, consistent with embodiments of thepresent disclosure. It will be readily appreciated that the illustratedprocedure can be altered to delete steps or further include additionalsteps. It is appreciated that one or more computing devices (such ascomputing device of FIG. 2) can perform the exemplary method and thatthe functionality described herein can be incorporated as hardware,software stored in the one or more computing devices, or any combinationthereof. Moreover, the illustrated procedure can be applied to manydifferent domains and descriptions related to a healthcare context arenot intended to limit the disclosure to only that domain. After initialstep 1001, the system (e.g., system 100 from FIG. 1) can obtain (step1010) data associated with individuals (e.g., professionals or, in ahealthcare context, physicians stored in data structure 400 of FIG. 4).Obtaining the data can include, as described in relation to FIG. 1extracting (e.g., using data extractor 111) the data from multiple datasources (e.g., data sources 101-104), transforming the data (e.g, usingdata transformer 112), and loading the data (e.g., using data loader113) into a storage location (e.g., data storage 115) for additionalanalysis. Through this process, the system can prepare data from avariety of sources into a normalized and consistent representation readyfor further processing.

The system can determine (step 1020) features (e.g., using featurediscovery engine 120) based on the data stored in the storage location(e.g., data storage 115). This data can include, among other things,physician data (e.g., data structure 400 of FIG. 4), claims data (e.g.,data structure 500 of FIG. 5), and prescription data (e.g., datastructure 600 of FIG. 6). Based on this data, the system can generatefeatures associated with physicians (e.g., data structure 700 of FIG.7).

The system can further label (step 1030) the feature data by determining(e.g., using label engine 130) which physicians are of higher and lowerquality. The identification of high and low quality physicians can bebased on the feature data. Certain features can be determined to besignals of good and bad physicians. For example, good physicians can beidentified as those who generate a large amount of RVUs when compared tosimilar physicians in the same specialty. Additional positive signalscan include features related to educational background, professionalrecognition, professional experience, or other identified signals.Examples of signals for negative labels include, among others,sanctions, reprimands, lack of scholarship, and patient complaints.After an initial set of physicians are labeled using these varioussignals, the nearest neighbors to labeled physicians can be calculatedto expand the number of labeled physicians.

After generating the labels, the system can generate (step 1040) a graph(e.g., using graph construction engine 142) representing similaritiesamong the physicians. The graph can include nodes representing eachphysicians and edges connecting the nodes that are similar. The numberof edges chosen can be based on various formulas including, amongothers, choosing k nearest neighbors, cosine similarity, Gaussian KernelSimilarity, or Euclidian distance similarity among the physicians.Furthermore, the system can use methods such as the Erdős-Rényi model tochoose enough edges to provide a fully connected graph while at the sametime reducing the computational complexity and noise to manageablelevels. After generating the graph, the system can further include thepositive and negative labels that were determined on the nodes of thegraph representing those identified physicians.

After generating the graph, the system can propagate (step 1050) thelabels (e.g., using label propagation engine 144) to the unlabeled nodesof the graph. The system can treat the positive and negative labels aspoint charges in an electrostatic system. The system can then calculatethe electrical potential of the nodes using equations for analyzingelectrical systems such as Laplace's equation or Poisson's equation. Theelectrical potential for each node can be converted into a relativeranking of physicians based on the calculated electrical potential ofeach node in the graph.

After propagating the labels, the system can order (step 1060) thephysicians based on the propagation of the labels. The relative orderingcan be based on the relative amount of the point charges calculated foreach of the nodes. The system can evaluate (step 1070) the ordering bydetermining the relevance of the ordered results. The system can useprocess such as DCG to determine the efficacy of the generated ordering.The result of the evaluations can be used to adjust the operation of theother parts of the system (e.g., feature discovery engine 120, labelengine 130, graph construction engine 142, and label propagation engine144).

Alternatively the system can provide (step 1075) the ordering for use(e.g., through app engine 170 or dashboard engine 180) by various usersof the system. These users can include individuals using the output tofind physicians or individuals using the system provide recommendationsabout physicians. Other uses for this information are possible, anddifferent outputs can be generated by adjusting the specific features,labels, and propagation methods used throughout the system.

Although the system is described in terms of a healthcare context, thesystem can be used for many different domains. The features used anddata that is input can be based on the nuances as specifics of thedomain being analyzed.

In the foregoing specification, embodiments have been described withreference to numerous specific details that can vary from implementationto implementation. Certain adaptations and modifications of thedescribed embodiments can be made. Other embodiments can be apparent tothose skilled in the art from consideration of the specification andpractice of the invention disclosed herein. It is intended that thespecification and examples be considered as exemplary only. It is alsointended that the sequence of steps shown in figures are only forillustrative purposes and are not intended to be limited to anyparticular sequence of steps. As such, those skilled in the art canappreciate that these steps can be performed in a different order whileimplementing the same method.

What is claimed is:
 1. A non-transitory computer readable storage medium storing instructions that are executable by a first computing device that includes one or more processors to cause the first computing device to perform a method comprising: obtaining, from one or more data sources, one or more data sets associated with a plurality of individuals; determining features associated with the plurality of individuals; determining similarities among the plurality of individuals based on the determined features; generating data representing a graph having a plurality of nodes, wherein the nodes of the graph are associated with the plurality of individuals, edges between the nodes represent the determined similarities, wherein the nodes include weighted nodes that are associated with a first subset of the plurality of individuals and unweighted nodes; applying a weight to the unweighted nodes of the graph, wherein the weights are based on an influence exerted by the weighted nodes on the unweighted nodes; providing output associated with the graph and the applied weights.
 2. The non-transitory computer readable storage medium of claim 1, wherein the graph is fully connected.
 3. The non-transitory computer readable storage medium of claim 1, wherein generating the graph utilizes a random graph model to select a subset of individuals to connect using edges on the graph.
 4. The non-transitory computer readable storage medium of claim 1, wherein the edges of the graph are weighted and the weight of an edge is based on the determined similarity between individuals associated with the nodes connected by the edge.
 5. The non-transitory computer readable storage medium of claim 1, wherein the first subset of plurality of individuals are labeled as exemplary comprises: one or more individuals of the first subset of individuals that are labeled as positive and one or more individuals of the first subset of individuals that are labeled as negative.
 6. The non-transitory computer readable storage medium of claim 5, further comprising: labeling the first subset of the plurality of individuals comprising: labeling a first set of individuals of the plurality of individuals as exemplary, wherein the first set of individuals includes at least one individual that is associated with a subset of features that is correlated to qualities associated with exemplary individuals; identifying a second set of individuals of the plurality of individuals that are similar to at least one individual of the first set, wherein the similarity is based on one or more features associated with the at least one individual and the second set of individuals; and labeling the second set of individuals as exemplary.
 7. The non-transitory computer readable storage medium of claim 1, wherein the influence of the weighted nodes on the unweighted nodes is determined using Poisson's equation, Laplace's equation, a Laplacian exponential diffusion kernel, a regularized Laplacian kernel, or a Von Neumann diffusion kernel.
 8. The non-transitory computer readable storage medium of claim 1, wherein providing the output further comprises providing the graph and the associated weights for processing by a client device.
 9. The non-transitory computer readable storage medium of claim 1, wherein providing output further comprises providing the output for display on a graphical user interface.
 10. An electronic device comprising: a data storage configured to store one or more data sets associated with a plurality of individuals; a feature discovery engine configured to: determine one or more features of the one or more data sets; a semi-supervised engine configured to: determine similarities among the plurality of individuals, based on the determined features; and generate data representing a graph having a plurality of nodes, wherein the nodes of the graph are associated with the plurality of individuals, edges between the nodes represent the determined similarities, wherein the nodes include weighted nodes that are associated with a first subset of the plurality of individuals and unweighted nodes; a label propagation engine configured to: applying a weight to the unweighted nodes of the graph, wherein the weights are based on an influence exerted by the weighted nodes on the unweighted nodes; and an evaluation engine configured to provide output associated with the graph and the applied weights.
 11. The electronic device of claim 10, wherein the semi-supervised engine utilizes a random graph model to select a subset of similar individuals to connect using edges on the graph.
 12. The electronic device of claim 10, wherein the edges of the graph are weighted and the weight of an edge is based on the determined similarity between the individuals represented by nodes connected by the edge.
 13. The electronic device of claim 10, further comprising: a label engine configured to: identify the first subset of the plurality of individuals as exemplary; and label the first subset as exemplary, wherein one or more individuals of the first subset are labeled as positive and one or more individuals of the first subset are labeled as negative.
 14. The electronic device of claim 13, wherein the label engine is configured to: label a first set of individuals of the plurality of individuals as exemplary wherein the first set of individuals includes at least one individual that is associated with a subset of features wherein the subset of features correlate to qualities associated with exemplary individuals; identify a second set of individuals of the plurality of individuals that are similar to at least one individual of the first set wherein the similarity is based on features associated with the at least one individual and the second set of individuals; label the second set of individuals as exemplary.
 15. The electronic device of claim 10, wherein the influence of the weighted nodes on the unweighted nodes is determined using Poisson's equation or Laplace's equation.
 16. A method performed by one or more processors and comprising: obtaining, from one or more data sources, one or more data sets associated with a plurality of individuals; determining features associated with the plurality of individuals; determining similarities among the plurality of individuals, based on the determined features; generating data representing a graph having a plurality of nodes, wherein the nodes of the graph are associated with the plurality of individuals, edges between the nodes represent the determined similarities, wherein the nodes include weighted nodes that are associated with a first subset of the plurality of individuals and unweighted nodes; applying a weight to the unweighted nodes of the graph, wherein the weights are based on an influence exerted by the weighted nodes on the unweighted nodes; providing output associated with the graph and the applied weights.
 17. The method of claim 16, wherein the edges of the graph are weighted and the weight of an edge is based on the determined similarity between individuals associated with the nodes connected by the edge.
 18. The method of claim 16, wherein one or more individuals of the first subset are labeled as positive and one or more individuals of the first subset are labeled as negative.
 19. The method of claim 16, further comprising: labeling one or more individuals of the first subset as exemplary comprising: labeling a first set of individuals of the plurality of individuals as exemplary, wherein the first set of individuals includes at least one individual that is associated with a subset of features that is correlated to qualities associated with exemplary individuals; identifying a second set of individuals of the plurality of individuals that are similar to at least one individual of the first set, wherein the similarity is based on one or more features associated with the at least one individual and the second set of individuals; and labeling the second set of individuals as exemplary
 20. The method of claim 16, wherein the influence exerted by the weighted nodes on the unweighted nodes is determined by assigning the weighted nodes point charges and calculating an electrical potential of the unweighted nodes. 